Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

ENC 1101 (Dauer) Life Scenario Essays: Evaluating Sources

The 5 Ws & 1 H

When evaluating a source, ask yourself Who? What? When? Where? Why? and How?. These questions can be shortened into "The 5 Ws & 1 H". 

Who made the information?

  • Identify the author (can be a person or group)
    • Can be located at top or bottom of source
  • Look for their qualifications. They should be an expert or qualified to write on the topic.
    • These can be listed in the "About Us" section of a website, there might be a few sentences under the author's name, or you might be able to click the author's name in a source to find out more about them. 
    • Check other sources. Open up a new tab in your browser and Google the author's name to find out more info

What information is in the source?

  • Does it meet your research need?
    • If it is off topic or doesn't meet your professor's requirements, find a better source
  • Is the information complete and comprehensive?
    • Stay away from sources that only present one side of the story or issue

When was the information created or updated?

  • An older source isn't necessarily a "bad source". If you're researching a historical event or timeless discipline like philosophy, an older source may be appropriate
  • Consider what you're researching. Is it a rapidly changing field like medicine or technology? Consider using newer sources

Where is the information coming from?

  • Is it from a reputable newspaper? A peer-reviewed journal? How about a casual blog? Or a news station that has a bad reputation?
    • Do some detective work to see if the organization, publisher, or source associated with your information is reliable
      • Look at other sources to see what they have to say 
        • example: Google The Wall Street Journal's reputation or BuzzFeed's reputation to get an idea about each organization

Why was the information created?

  • Think about purpose. To inform? Entertain? Persuade? Sell?
  • Is the source strongly biased?
    • Some degree of bias is unavoidable, but keep an eye out for over exaggerated, emotional word choice and tone

How is the information verified?

  • Are there links that show you where the author got their information from?
  • Is there a citation list?
  • Was the source peer-reviewed? 
    • Remember, peer-review is a process where a source is reviewed by a panel of experts for accuracy and quality. Once revisions are made, the source is published

 

Use It Or Lose It